Des questions que les Shi'ah n'aiment pas répondre | Some Questions that the Shi'ah Don't Like to Answer

[Français]

Quelques questions à poser aux Shi‘ah

1. Les Shi‘ah croient que ‘Ali (radiAllahu ‘Anhu) était infaillible. Néanmoins, nous constatons – comme avoué par les Shi‘ah eux-mêmes – qu’il a donné sa fille Umm Kulthum, la propre sœur d’al-Hassan et d’al-Hussayn (RadiAllahu ‘Anhum), en mariage à ‘Umar ibn Al-Khattâb (RadiAllahu ‘Anhu). Les Shi‘ah ici doivent accepter un des deux choix amères :

Premier choix : Que ‘Ali (radiAllahu ‘Anhu) n’était pas infaillible, car il a donné sa fille en mariage a un incroyant et croire en cela contredit certainement le fondement principal de l’idéologie chiite. Non seulement cela, mais ça annule aussi la réclamation d’infaillibilité de tous les autres Imams qui sont venus après lui.

Deuxième choix : Que ‘Umar (radiAllahu ‘Anhu) était Musulman et que ‘Ali a accepté d’être son beau-père et a accepté ‘Umar comme beau-fils.

2. Les Shi‘ah prétendent qu’Abû Bakr et ‘Umar (radiAllahu ‘Anhum) étaient incroyants. Mais nous constatons que ‘Ali (radiAllahu ‘Anhu), un Imam infaillible selon les Shi‘ah, a accepté et a approuvé leurs califats et a prêté allégeance à chacun d’eux. Pourquoi? Cela annule-t-il l’infaillibilité de ‘Ali ou prouve-t-il que ‘Umar était un Musulman?


~ via The Final Revelation

------------------------

[English]

Some questions to ask shi`as

1. The Shias believe that Ali (radiAllahu Anhu) was infallible. Nevertheless, we find him – as confessed by the shias themseleves – giving his daughter Umm Kulthum, the full sister of al-Hasan and Husaain (RadiAllahu Anhu), in marriage to Umar ibn Al Khattab (Radiallahu `anhu). The Shias must here accept one of two bitter choices:

First: That Ali (r) was not infallible, for he gave his daughter in marriage to an unbeliever and to believe this definitely contradicts the main foundation of the Shia Ideology. Not only this, it goes further to nullify the claim of infallibility of all other imams who came after him.

Second: That Umar (r) was a Muslim and that Ali accepted to be his father in law and accepted him to be his son-in-law.

Q2: The Shias claim that Abu Bakr and Umar (r.a.a) were unbelievers. But we find that Ali (r.a), an infallible Imam according to the shias, accepted and endorsed their caliphates and pledged his allegiance to each of them, one after the other and never revolted against them., Why? Does this take away Ali's infallibility or prove `Umar was a Muslim ?


~ via The Final Revelation